India

Delhi High Court Rules Aadhaar Card Alone Cannot Conclude Date of Birth

By GS Team
20 Nov 20263 mins read
TukuTouch Logo
Delhi High Court rules Aadhaar isn't conclusive proof of date of birth, upholding a labour court decision against an employer who prematurely retired an employee based on conflicting age records. The court clarified Aadhaar is proof of identity, not definitive birth date evidence, citing UIDAI's stance on self-declared data.

Summarized by AI; it may make mistakes. Check important info

Delhi High Court Rules Aadhaar Card Alone Cannot Conclude Date of Birth

An Aadhaar card cannot be treated as conclusive proof of a person's date of birth, the Delhi High Court has ruled, dismissing an employer's attempt to force an employee into early retirement based on conflicting age records.

In an order passed on November 13, Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri rejected a petition filed by JJ Electronics challenging a labour court decision. The lower court had refused to accept an employee's Aadhaar details as definitive proof of her age, ruling in favour of the worker who was terminated a year ahead of her scheduled retirement.

The Dispute Over Conflicting Records

The legal battle began after JJ Electronics terminated the services of Rosamma Joy, who worked at the firm as a "finishing man". The company acted after spotting a discrepancy in her year of birth across official records.

While Joy's Aadhaar card listed her year of birth as 1959, records submitted to the Employees' State Insurance Corporation (ESIC) mentioned 1960. Relying solely on the Aadhaar entry, the management contended that Joy had already attained the retirement age of 58 and ended her employment a year early.

Joy challenged her dismissal before the labour court, seeking reinstatement alongside full back wages. The labour court declined to accept the Aadhaar card as final evidence of her age, pointing out that no witness from the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) had been examined to verify the basis on which the date was entered. Accepting 1960 as her year of birth as reflected in the records, the labour court ordered the company to grant her back wages and consequential benefits.

What the Delhi High Court Ruled

Upholding the labour court's verdict, the Delhi High Court clarified that the legal framework governing Aadhaar recognises it as proof of identity, rather than conclusive evidence of a person's date of birth.

Justice Ohri referred to a 2018 office memorandum issued by UIDAI, which explicitly states that the date of birth printed on an Aadhaar card is recorded based on documents or a self-declaration provided by the cardholder at the time of enrolment.

Accepting Joy's submissions, the High Court observed that she had not reached the age of superannuation in 2017. Pointing out that ESIC records clearly listed her date of birth as May 20, 1960, the court held that the employer could not rely on a different date on her Aadhaar card to bring forward her retirement by a year. The High Court also endorsed the labour court's finding that Joy's termination was illegal, as JJ Electronics had failed to comply with the relevant provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act.