Why is police paid salaries if not working efficiently, asks Gujarat HC
Updated: Jan 30th, 2025
A Gujarat High Court bench of Justice A S Supehia and Justice Gita Gopi have taken to task police officers who are inefficient, questioning whether they deserved their salaries if they failed to perform their duties properly.
The remarks came during the hearing of a contempt petition filed by advocate Amit Panchal pertaining to stray cattle, deteriorating roads, illegal parking and encroachment on footpaths.
During the hearing, Justice Supehia shared a personal experience at a T-junction where there was heavy traffic despite a police station being just 200 metres away. Upon getting out of his car to assess the situation, he observed a traffic constable inside the police station using his mobile phone instead of managing the traffic.
Sharing this, he questioned, “What are these constables being paid for?” and criticised the police department for its inefficiency.
The court further highlighted that road encroachments have increased, and even when stalls are seized, people often remain, sit, and protest, occupying 50% of the road space. As a result, there is no space left for vehicles or pedestrians.
The court directed the authorities to permanently remove encroachments and ensure they do not return.
Advocate Amit Panchal pointed out that despite the case ongoing for the past 6-7 years with 102 hearings and 62 court orders, the authorities have failed to take appropriate action or comply with the court’s directives. He urged the court to take strict action against those responsible and move the case forward.
The next hearing is scheduled for February 6.
Case hearing highlights
Traffic jams and encroachments
The court noted that people are severely affected by traffic congestion and encroachments on roads. Authorities only seem to act during court hearings and revert to inaction afterward.
Lack of law enforcement
Despite having laws in place, enforcement is poor. The court stressed that legal compliance should occur even in the absence of court hearings.
Strict measures necessary
Court assistant Bhaskar Tanna emphasised that “fear is essential for compliance”. He suggested implementing strict penalties and effective surveillance through cameras to address the situation.
Non-compliance by authorities
The court criticised authorities for failing to implement its orders, terming it a violation and disrespect of the High Court’s directives. The court indicated that charges may be filed against responsible officers.
Ineffective parking policy and Road Safety Act
The court also noted that Ahmedabad’s 2021 Parking Policy and the Gujarat Road Safety Act of 2018 have not been implemented effectively. Illegal encroachments on roads, footpaths, and public spaces are rampant.
Also read :
